Specific tax and tax incidence

Specific tax and tax incidence · 40 / 80 · Structured · self-assessed

Question

Case A: After a specific tax, buyers pay $86 more per unit and sellers receive $71 less net per unit, other things equal. Case B: After a specific tax, buyers pay $83 more per unit and sellers receive $33 less net per unit, other things equal. A classmate concludes that specific tax per unit ($) is higher in case A. Assess the claim using both cases. Identify one mistake to avoid when interpreting the result.